Skip to content

Article

The Battle of Mu'tah: victory, defeat or strategic retreat?

The first clash with the Byzantine world, told from the hadith and the early biographies, and then as modern historians tell it.

7 min readBattles and campaigns

The Battle of Mu'tah was fought in Jumada al-Ula 8 AH (September 629 CE) near the village of Mu'tah, in present-day Jordan, between a Muslim army of about 3,000 sent by the Prophet ﷺ and Byzantine forces with their Arab allies. The three commanders he appointed, Zayd ibn Harithah, Ja'far ibn Abi Talib and Abdullah ibn Rawahah, were killed one after another. Khalid ibn al-Walid then took the banner and brought the army home. The Prophet ﷺ said that Allah made them victorious. Historians outside the Islamic tradition tell the story with a different emphasis and often call it inconclusive or a Byzantine success. This article sets out both accounts.

Why the army was sent

According to the early biographies, the Prophet ﷺ had sent an envoy, al-Harith ibn Umayr al-Azdi, with a letter for the ruler of Busra. Shurahbil ibn Amr, a Ghassanid chief who was a vassal of the Byzantine Empire, killed him. Killing an envoy was a grave breach of the rules of the age, and the Prophet ﷺ sent an army to answer it. This was months after the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah and the Umrah the Muslims made up the year after, and shortly after Khalid ibn al-Walid had accepted Islam.

It was the first time the Muslims marched against a force backed by the Byzantine Empire. The Prophet ﷺ did not go himself. In the technical language of the seerah it is therefore a sariyyah (an expedition he did not lead in person), although Sahih al-Bukhari calls it a ghazwah.

The three commanders

Abdullah ibn Umar, who was present, said that the Prophet ﷺ appointed Zayd ibn Harithah as commander and said: if Zayd is martyred, Ja'far takes over, and if Ja'far is martyred, Abdullah ibn Rawahah takes over (Sahih al-Bukhari 4261). Each of the three has a place in the story of the Prophet ﷺ:

  • Zayd ibn Harithah was the Prophet's ﷺ freed slave and adopted son. He is the only Companion named in the Quran (33:37).
  • Ja'far ibn Abi Talib, the Prophet's ﷺ cousin, had spoken for the Muslims before the king of Abyssinia.
  • Abdullah ibn Rawahah was an Ansari and one of the poets who answered Quraysh in verse.

Putting these three first was a sign of how much the Prophet ﷺ trusted them, and of the danger of the post: the commander carried the banner at the front.

The Islamic account of the battle

The early biographies say the Muslims reached the area of Ma'an and learned that a very large Byzantine army and its Arab allies had gathered. Some wanted to write to the Prophet ﷺ for orders. Abdullah ibn Rawahah answered that they had not come for numbers but for martyrdom or victory, and the army went on.

Zayd fell holding the banner, then Ja'far, then Abdullah ibn Rawahah. Ibn Umar searched for Ja'far among the martyrs and found over ninety wounds in his body (Sahih al-Bukhari 4261). Another report in Bukhari has him counting fifty wounds, none of them in the back (Sahih al-Bukhari 4260). Ja'far was remembered as "the one with two wings": Ibn Umar greeted his son with the words "peace be on you, son of the two-winged one" (Sahih al-Bukhari 4264). The early biographies explain the title by saying he lost both hands holding the banner.

After the third commander fell, the army chose a leader. The biographies say Thabit ibn Aqram took the banner and, when the men turned to him, handed it to Khalid ibn al-Walid. Khalid said of the day: "Nine swords broke in my hand at Mu'tah, and only a Yemeni sword of mine was left" (Sahih al-Bukhari 4265). The early historians report that he rearranged the lines during the night, moving the front to the back and the flanks across, so that the enemy would believe fresh troops had arrived. The Muslims then drew off, and the Byzantines did not pursue.

What the Prophet ﷺ said in Madinah

Anas reported that the Prophet ﷺ told the people of the deaths of Zayd, Ja'far and Ibn Rawahah before any news came. He said that Zayd took the banner and was martyred, then Ja'far, then Ibn Rawahah, and his eyes were shedding tears. Then, he said, the banner was taken by "a sword among the swords of Allah", and Allah made the Muslims victorious (Sahih al-Bukhari 4262). That is where Khalid's title, Sayfullah, the Sword of Allah, comes from.

Aishah described the Prophet ﷺ sitting with grief plain on his face when the news arrived. A man told him that the women of Ja'far's house were crying, and he told them to stop. The man came back twice to say they would not listen (Sahih al-Bukhari 4263). The loss of Zayd, whom he had raised, and of his cousin was a real grief to him. Read with the first report, it also shows the Muslims were told of the outcome, grief and victory together, from Madinah.

Was it a victory?

Muslim scholars have given different answers, and the question depends on what one means by victory.

  • A victory. The Prophet's ﷺ own words that Allah made them victorious (Sahih al-Bukhari 4262) are the strongest evidence. The army was saved from destruction, relatively few Muslims died, and the Arabs of the region saw that the Muslims had met the great power of the age and returned.
  • A strategic withdrawal. Others stress that Khalid judged the field was not one on which to fight a much larger and better trained force, and that to withdraw was the wise course. The aim of the expedition was to answer an envoy's killing, not to conquer territory.
  • A report that some fled. A report from Ibn Umar says that when the army withdrew, some turned back to Madinah feeling they had fled. The Prophet ﷺ is said to have told them they were al-akkarun, those who turn back to fight again, and that he was their support (Jami' al-Tirmidhi 1716; Sunan Abi Dawud 2647). Al-Tirmidhi called it hasan gharib, but al-Albani, Ahmad Shakir and Zubair Ali Zai graded it weak, so it should not be taken as settled.

The numbers

The early Muslim historians, such as Ibn Ishaq and al-Waqidi, say the Muslims were told of 100,000 Byzantines and as many Arab allies. Medieval writers often used large round numbers to say that a force was very big, as the Arabic use of seventy or a thousand shows elsewhere, and some modern writers estimate the force at ten thousand or fewer, given the size of the Byzantine field armies of the time. The Muslim army was about 3,000. Whatever the exact figures, all accounts agree that the Muslims were heavily outnumbered, and that battlefield experience was on the other side.

The academic account

Modern historians who work from Byzantine and other non-Muslim sources have little to read about Mu'tah, because the empire had other worries, and they usually place the event within a longer series of raids on the Byzantine frontier in the 620s and 630s. The Byzantine chronicler Theophanes (died about 818) describes a clash in the region in which a Byzantine official named Theodorus gathered the local garrisons, and some historians, Walter Kaegi among them, link the passage to Mu'tah. The link is not certain, and Theophanes wrote almost two centuries afterwards and places the clash at a different time, so scholars treat it with care.

On this reading, the result is often described as a Byzantine success, or as inconclusive, because the Muslims lost their three commanders and withdrew. The Islamic account does not contradict the military facts: three commanders fell, the army withdrew and the Byzantines did not pursue. The difference is in the measure of success. The Prophet ﷺ spoke of victory, and the sources that frame it so are the ones closest to him. Outside the tradition, a battle in which a commander retreats is usually counted a loss. Both agree on what happened, and the Islamic account adds what it meant.

Why it matters

Mu'tah was the first meeting with the Byzantine world, and it prepared the ground for what followed: the expedition to Tabuk the next year, and the campaigns in Syria under Abu Bakr and Umar, led by Khalid, whom the Prophet ﷺ had named the Sword of Allah. His life is told in the profile of Khalid ibn al-Walid, and what came after on Athar in Umar and the expansion. The expedition also shows the Muslim community learning to act without the Prophet ﷺ at its head, with a clear line of succession in the field.

Sources

  • Sahih al-Bukhari 4260, 4261, 4262, 4263, 4264, 4265 and 4266 (the narrations of Ibn Umar, Anas, Aishah and Khalid): https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/gh/fawazahmed0/hadith-api@1/editions/eng-bukhari/4261.json
  • Jami' al-Tirmidhi 1716, graded weak by al-Albani, Ahmad Shakir and Zubair Ali Zai: https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/gh/fawazahmed0/hadith-api@1/editions/eng-tirmidhi/1716.json
  • Sunan Abi Dawud 2647, graded weak by al-Albani, Muhyi al-Din Abd al-Hamid, Shuaib al-Arnaut and Zubair Ali Zai: https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/gh/fawazahmed0/hadith-api@1/editions/eng-abudawud/2647.json
  • Quran 33:37 (Zayd named): https://quran.com/33/37
  • The Conquest of Jordan, Karak Resources Project (on Theophanes and the Byzantine response): https://www.karakresourcesproject.org/conquest-of-jordan
  • Battle of Mu'tah, reference article (date, 3,000 men, the command sequence and the range of estimates for the enemy): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Mu%27tah

Questions & answers

Common questions

Short answers from this article.

Where and when was the Battle of Mu'tah?

It was fought in Jumada al-Ula 8 AH (September 629 CE) near the village of Mu'tah in present-day Jordan, near Karak, between a Muslim army of about 3,000 and Byzantine forces with their Ghassanid and other Arab allies.

Read more: The Battle of Mu'tah: victory, defeat or strategic retreat?

Who were the three commanders at Mu'tah?

Zayd ibn Harithah, Ja'far ibn Abi Talib and Abdullah ibn Rawahah, appointed in that order by the Prophet ﷺ (Sahih al-Bukhari 4261). All three were killed, one after another, and Khalid ibn al-Walid then took the banner.

Read more: The Battle of Mu'tah: victory, defeat or strategic retreat?

Why was Khalid ibn al-Walid called the Sword of Allah?

Because the Prophet ﷺ, telling the people in Madinah of the battle, said that the banner was taken by a sword among the swords of Allah, and Allah made the Muslims victorious (Sahih al-Bukhari 4262).

Read more: The Battle of Mu'tah: victory, defeat or strategic retreat?

Was the Battle of Mu'tah a victory or a defeat?

The Prophet ﷺ said Allah made the Muslims victorious, and many scholars treat it as a victory or a wise withdrawal that saved the army. Historians who rely on non-Muslim sources often call it inconclusive or a Byzantine success. Both accounts agree that three commanders fell and the army withdrew without being destroyed.

Read more: The Battle of Mu'tah: victory, defeat or strategic retreat?

How many soldiers fought at Mu'tah?

The Muslim army was about 3,000. Early Muslim historians give the enemy as 100,000 or 200,000, which many modern writers read as a very large force, and some estimate it at ten thousand or fewer.

Read more: The Battle of Mu'tah: victory, defeat or strategic retreat?